Alta receives FIM Homologation for North America 250 class

Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
Edited Date/Time 4/21/2018 11:16pm
I can't find any press release, but it is stated in this article:

"The team at Alta Motors received homologation for FIM North America competition in the 250 class. This unlocks Canada and propels them halfway closer to AMA Supercross, where they really want to race. They have big plans this offseason. Alta Motors is returning to Red Bull Straight Rhythm and including additional European Supercross events. "

https://thumpertalk.com/articles/electric-motorcycles-are-coming-r722/

|
ruy
Posts
4092
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
España ES
9/9/2017 8:59am
Good!
gt80rider
Posts
6275
Joined
4/19/2008
Location
Boulder, CO US
9/9/2017 9:11am Edited Date/Time 9/9/2017 9:11am
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are they gonna tech the motors? The cells? Is there a max cell count? Max kV? Power output changes with gearing, so is it that locked?

So many questions...
MxKing809
Posts
6380
Joined
10/13/2013
Location
Big Sand Whoops, MI US
Fantasy
315th
9/9/2017 9:22am
gt80rider wrote:
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are...
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are they gonna tech the motors? The cells? Is there a max cell count? Max kV? Power output changes with gearing, so is it that locked?

So many questions...
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open development until it hits that tipping point of fairness, then rein it back in.

The Shop

Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
9/9/2017 9:32am
gt80rider wrote:
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are...
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are they gonna tech the motors? The cells? Is there a max cell count? Max kV? Power output changes with gearing, so is it that locked?

So many questions...
MxKing809 wrote:
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open...
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open development until it hits that tipping point of fairness, then rein it back in.
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to get approved.
kkawboy14
Posts
11494
Joined
6/5/2015
Location
TX US
9/9/2017 9:33am
gt80rider wrote:
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are...
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are they gonna tech the motors? The cells? Is there a max cell count? Max kV? Power output changes with gearing, so is it that locked?

So many questions...
MxKing809 wrote:
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open...
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open development until it hits that tipping point of fairness, then rein it back in.
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to...
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to get approved.
They can rate hp of anything
Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
9/9/2017 9:35am
I wonder if Cheed Rad or team Stewart would give them a go in the big boy class?
skiz
Posts
109
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
Wadsworth, OH US
9/9/2017 9:43am
MxKing809 wrote:
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open...
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open development until it hits that tipping point of fairness, then rein it back in.
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to...
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to get approved.
kkawboy14 wrote:
They can rate hp of anything
So you would favor deciding if they could race 250 or 450 based on HP.?
Sounds reasonable.

To Johnny Depp I would ask, if I invented a bike that could accelerate like a railgun, would it stifle innovation to be told that I could only race in the 450 class and not the 250 class.?

How do you define "put your finger on the scale".?
MxKing809
Posts
6380
Joined
10/13/2013
Location
Big Sand Whoops, MI US
Fantasy
315th
9/9/2017 10:08am
gt80rider wrote:
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are...
This is cool to see they can officially race... However.... How in the world is that even possible? Who is gonna tech the motors? How are they gonna tech the motors? The cells? Is there a max cell count? Max kV? Power output changes with gearing, so is it that locked?

So many questions...
MxKing809 wrote:
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open...
It won't matter until they win, then the rule book will be written to hold them back. And I think that's how it should be. Open development until it hits that tipping point of fairness, then rein it back in.
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to...
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to get approved.
I actually think we agree, but I may not have articulated it well.

I don't think they should restrict anything, as to not stifle innovation, UNTIL the electric bikes are too advanced to compete fairly with 250's. Then possibably bump them up to the 450 class, or restrict them.
gt80rider
Posts
6275
Joined
4/19/2008
Location
Boulder, CO US
9/9/2017 10:29am
skiz wrote:
So you would favor deciding if they could race 250 or 450 based on HP.? Sounds reasonable. To Johnny Depp I would ask, if I invented...
So you would favor deciding if they could race 250 or 450 based on HP.?
Sounds reasonable.

To Johnny Depp I would ask, if I invented a bike that could accelerate like a railgun, would it stifle innovation to be told that I could only race in the 450 class and not the 250 class.?

How do you define "put your finger on the scale".?
See, that's the problem, it is extremely hard to get a direct equivalent between a brushless/lithium power system compared to gas. That's why I am amazed they are officially sanctioning direct competition between the two. Should it be 250 or 450? The real answer is neither.
JW381
Posts
10642
Joined
7/21/2009
Location
Harrisburg, OR US
9/9/2017 10:35am
Damn, badass!
Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
9/9/2017 10:53am
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to...
Sorry, I disagree with that concept. Don't stifle innovation or put your finger on the scale. Too many dumb rules already, they shouldn't even need to get approved.
kkawboy14 wrote:
They can rate hp of anything
skiz wrote:
So you would favor deciding if they could race 250 or 450 based on HP.? Sounds reasonable. To Johnny Depp I would ask, if I invented...
So you would favor deciding if they could race 250 or 450 based on HP.?
Sounds reasonable.

To Johnny Depp I would ask, if I invented a bike that could accelerate like a railgun, would it stifle innovation to be told that I could only race in the 450 class and not the 250 class.?

How do you define "put your finger on the scale".?
Most of us still have a real bad taste in our mouth from the way "fairness" was dealt out when 4 strokes came along. Tastes like doo-doo. Someone named Honda had their finger on the scale, and still do.

Separate discussion, but I am not an advocate of classes defined by HP or CC so I have no allegiance to protect the Pro Circuit and Geico's( or the sandbagger's) of the 250 class.
MX Guy
Posts
2209
Joined
7/18/2016
Location
Murrieta, CA US
Fantasy
668th
9/9/2017 10:56am
skiz wrote:
So you would favor deciding if they could race 250 or 450 based on HP.? Sounds reasonable. To Johnny Depp I would ask, if I invented...
So you would favor deciding if they could race 250 or 450 based on HP.?
Sounds reasonable.

To Johnny Depp I would ask, if I invented a bike that could accelerate like a railgun, would it stifle innovation to be told that I could only race in the 450 class and not the 250 class.?

How do you define "put your finger on the scale".?
gt80rider wrote:
See, that's the problem, it is extremely hard to get a direct equivalent between a brushless/lithium power system compared to gas. That's why I am amazed...
See, that's the problem, it is extremely hard to get a direct equivalent between a brushless/lithium power system compared to gas. That's why I am amazed they are officially sanctioning direct competition between the two. Should it be 250 or 450? The real answer is neither.
Having ridden one I can tell you it will absolutely smoke a 250 four stroke with ease on a track like Glen Helen for example, those hills would be nothing for the Alta where a 250 needs to shift once or twice, depending.

They're going to have to restrict the top end power of that thing to stay in line with 250's, that's my take.
Motodave15
Posts
4260
Joined
8/7/2010
Location
Temple City, CA US
9/9/2017 11:28am
This is exciting... I hope to see this electric bike win. As for the rules, they have to allow it to race to see where it matches up... And you will only be able to get the needed data from pro level racing.
FolkLoar
Posts
346
Joined
2/18/2015
Location
Hickory, NC US
9/9/2017 11:40am
I wonder how the other manufacturers feel about this? If their finger is on the scale as much as some some suggest, you would think they would want this pushed back till they had their own electric technology read to market.
Or did they set a precedent with the four stroke introduction to racing that is now hurting them when it comes to electrics. Where Alta can basically say, "hey AMA look how the four stroke technology came into racing why not us?" I might be way off and the current manufacturers could be 100% on board with it, who knows?
Falcon
Posts
10111
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
Fantasy
798th
9/9/2017 11:42am
Fantastic. I hope they whoop some ass in the nationals next year.
aeffertz
Posts
9275
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
Eau Claire, WI US
9/9/2017 11:50am Edited Date/Time 9/9/2017 11:51am
The current Alta can't even come close to 450 numbers. Why do some of you think they should put it up against them?

Cool news though. Will be interesting to see how they stack up against the 250s in the pro ranks.
skiz
Posts
109
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
Wadsworth, OH US
9/9/2017 11:53am
Motodave15 wrote:
This is exciting... I hope to see this electric bike win. As for the rules, they have to allow it to race to see where it...
This is exciting... I hope to see this electric bike win. As for the rules, they have to allow it to race to see where it matches up... And you will only be able to get the needed data from pro level racing.
Racing Orgs have always matched up/categorized bikes according to CCs. But CCs isn't the samething as power output.

Compare this to the light bulb. For decades we were told that bulbs were 60watt bulbs. But then CFLs and LEDs came along and the packages said, "equivalent to 60watt". Those of us that looked further into it found that light output is measured at 800 Lumens for the classic incandescent light bulb we used all of those decades. So Lumens was what we should have been aware of this entire time.

If we stop focusing on motorcycle CCs, what should we be looking at.?
JM485
Posts
5405
Joined
10/1/2013
Location
Davis, CA US
9/9/2017 11:55am Edited Date/Time 9/9/2017 11:57am
I think the only way they could realistically limit the power is by limiting the kW hrs of the battery. By limiting the capacity, it limits the amount of power that can be drawn in a given time. Here's a quick example:

Let's say you have a 10 kW hr battery. Depending on you application, you could draw 10kW for an hour until the battery is dead, or you could draw 20kW for half an hour and get higher performance. By doing it this way, power can be limited since the battery has to last 15 min at full power, which limits how much they can draw during the race. Yes, electric motors can be rated by HP, but that is a pretty bad way to go about it for this type of application.

I'm far from an expert on this but from my engineering background I know a little, so that is my theory about how to go about it. Awesome to see them racing, I'm glad they are making progress and really making a push in other types of racing while they wait on getting into the big show.
Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
9/9/2017 11:57am Edited Date/Time 9/9/2017 12:48pm
All of these theories about how you could measure it are exactly why you shouldn't even try. You are chasing your tail. Let them race for at least a year as a "prototype" mulligan and then put them in whatever fits.
APLMAN99
Posts
10099
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Dallas, TX US
9/9/2017 11:58am
aeffertz wrote:
The current Alta can't even come close to 450 numbers. Why do some of you think they should put it up against them? Cool news though...
The current Alta can't even come close to 450 numbers. Why do some of you think they should put it up against them?

Cool news though. Will be interesting to see how they stack up against the 250s in the pro ranks.
What 459 "numbers" are you referring to?
scott_nz
Posts
5320
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NZ
Fantasy
655th
9/9/2017 12:04pm
I can't find any press release, but it is stated in this article: "The team at Alta Motors received homologation for FIM North America competition in...
I can't find any press release, but it is stated in this article:

"The team at Alta Motors received homologation for FIM North America competition in the 250 class. This unlocks Canada and propels them halfway closer to AMA Supercross, where they really want to race. They have big plans this offseason. Alta Motors is returning to Red Bull Straight Rhythm and including additional European Supercross events. "

https://thumpertalk.com/articles/electric-motorcycles-are-coming-r722/

i thought the Canadian national moto series ran outside the CMA which is the FIM affiliate there?

does this mean it is ok for GP's?
Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
9/9/2017 12:05pm Edited Date/Time 9/9/2017 12:09pm


The blue line of interrupted torque or power delivery with a gearbox is exactly why the Alta works well. No Chassis interruption of traction between gear changes, let alone the power drop.

If I had an Alta the 1st thing I'd do is drop a bunch of teeth on the rear sprocket, with that torque it should pull it like a boss.
Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
9/9/2017 12:22pm
I can't find any press release, but it is stated in this article: "The team at Alta Motors received homologation for FIM North America competition in...
I can't find any press release, but it is stated in this article:

"The team at Alta Motors received homologation for FIM North America competition in the 250 class. This unlocks Canada and propels them halfway closer to AMA Supercross, where they really want to race. They have big plans this offseason. Alta Motors is returning to Red Bull Straight Rhythm and including additional European Supercross events. "

https://thumpertalk.com/articles/electric-motorcycles-are-coming-r722/

scott_nz wrote:
i thought the Canadian national moto series ran outside the CMA which is the FIM affiliate there?

does this mean it is ok for GP's?
I haven't found that answer, and I have searched. Maybe Marc from Alta will drop in and enlighten us a bit?
skiz
Posts
109
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
Wadsworth, OH US
9/9/2017 12:44pm
Up thru 02 in Europe and 93 in the USA, we had 3 classes, little bikes, mid bikes, and 500s. Is there any consideration of having 3 categories again, 250, 450, and E.? Those could also be the MxdN categories. Change the Open category to an Electric category and give it a decade or half decade to see if it is supported at all levels of factory, team, and fans interest.
GuyB
Posts
35699
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
Fantasy
988th
9/9/2017 12:47pm
I didn't read anything in there that would equate to AMA homologation.
NorCal 50+
Posts
1457
Joined
5/31/2017
Location
Grass Valley, CA US
9/9/2017 1:00pm
These things need their own class, IMO. It's a totally different technology.

Post a reply to: Alta receives FIM Homologation for North America 250 class

The Latest