btn
btn
1 of 3
Create New Tag
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 7:58 AM

Hello all! We're opening up our eyes and ears by taking on your questions about Vital MX's 2019 450 Shootout. Pretty simple in here, if you have a question about the test itself, fire away. If you have a question to a specific test rider about their opinions, I'm here of course (Michael Lindsay), Manny Ornellas is a forum regular and I'm sure we can sucker Sean Klinger to making a few stops in here, while the other testers (Blake Savage, Chris Hay, Zach Peddie, and Derrick Caskey)are but a text away for me. I can forward on those questions and see if I can wrangle up an answer.

Btw, here's the link to the article, in case you haven't seen it: https://www.vitalmx.com/features/2019-Vital-MX-450-Shootout,6162

Lastly, we're curious what you, the reader, think of the actual Shootout. Too long, just right, too short (I doubt that, ha)...and what the context in which we cover it. We appreciate any feedback you might have.

Photo

| Quote
nage0139 nage0139
8/20/2018 8:47 AM

ML, I know it was mentioned in the video and early on in the article about having the LITPro data available this year per rider per bike: is that coming out at a later time? Not that it's going to sway my opinion, but I think it would be interesting to see as a viewer.

Also, what would the best bike have from each of the six contender bikes (i.e. clutch from the Kawi, forks from the Yam, brakes of the KTM, etc.)?

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 9:08 AM
nage0139 wrote:

ML, I know it was ...more

I'm heading down to their office in a bit to go over it with them. I'll get it available. smile

As for that answer, that depends on each rider as you can see we like different traits about each bike and some of us don't agree on which of those traits are good or bad.

| Quote
mxrose3 mxrose3
8/20/2018 10:54 AM

Excellent write up ML!

Can't wait to see the LITPro data as well....

| Quote
spacecat spacecat
8/20/2018 11:21 AM

What is the number for the new renthal handlebar on the crf? I would like to try them on my 2018. Sounds like an answer to what I have been searching for.

| Quote
RF219 RF219
8/20/2018 12:11 PM

dyno charts?

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 12:38 PM
RF219 wrote:

dyno charts?

Having to pull them from elsewhere, working on it.

| Quote
MXVet261 MXVet261
8/20/2018 12:42 PM

Having a hard time telling from the pics, but does the KX still come with 7/8" bars? How could that be possible?

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 12:58 PM
MXVet261 wrote:

Having a hard time telling ...more

Yup, still does. Only one left in the 450 class.

| Quote
Rotaholic Rotaholic
8/20/2018 1:20 PM

Interesting that the suzuki is only 1 pound heavier than the yami (6th vs 1st) I know it needs to go on a diet but not as bad as everyone makes out.

| Quote
dura max dura max
8/20/2018 1:25 PM

Which bike had the least amount of engine braking? How would you rank them in order of engine braking from least to most? Seems like more and more manufacturers are focusing on creating a free revving engine character. In past years, I recall the Yamaha having the worst engine braking which kept me away from it.

| Quote
adamdf adamdf
8/20/2018 1:26 PM

Hi Michael,

First off, great work with the shootout! I had just one question, I noticed that the one tester who rated the Husky 2nd commented that he used the "Quick" throttle cam during his test and which improved things for him , did the rest of the testers try the Quick cam?

Overall, what I take from this shootout is that the top 5 bikes are all excellent machines which can be tuned with simple adjustments to make almost any rider happy. As someone that rides the 2017 for the last year and a half, I am not too concerned with the result this year , it just shows how great the bikes are this year.

Adam

17 KTM 450 SXF - AMAZING!

| Quote
datkin128 datkin128
8/20/2018 2:12 PM
Rotaholic wrote:

Interesting that the ...more

That's before they add electric start like everyone else has...

| Quote
datkin128 datkin128
8/20/2018 2:14 PM

There seemed to be a lot of comments about bar bend which seems totally personal. What bar bends seem to be the most preferred among the group if they could pick exactly what they wanted?

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 3:09 PM
adamdf wrote:

Hi Michael,

First off, ...more

I’m pretty sure we all did and I think after a bit they just left it in, I forgot to note it in my write up, it was a big improvement, I was over gripping it on the stock cam a ton to get it turned all the way. Since I kept going to wide open on the Husky since it was so smooth/mellow.

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 3:11 PM
datkin128 wrote:

There seemed to be a lot ...more

I think most of us have a personal one we like more than others. Between myself, Caskey, Peddie, and Hay...probably even Klinger, none of us seem to like the same bars.

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 3:12 PM
Rotaholic wrote:

Interesting that the ...more

The engine inertia it displaced plus the placement of that weight makes it feel a solid five pounds heavier than the next heaviest feeling bike once on track, at least for me.

| Quote
adamdf adamdf
8/20/2018 3:18 PM
adamdf wrote:

Hi Michael,

First off, ...more

ML512 wrote:

I’m pretty sure we all did ...more

Thanks, good to know!

17 KTM 450 SXF - AMAZING!

| Quote
tmauto769 tmauto769
8/20/2018 5:26 PM

I think Vital's shootouts are the best out there. Good work!
With the Yamaha app, do you have to have the bike running while you are changing the maps? (like you have to do with the get wifi on the crf's)

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/20/2018 5:40 PM
tmauto769 wrote:

I think Vital's shootouts ...more

Nope, just hit the starter button and the system goes active for a couple mins, just hit the starter for split second again to reset that time. The bike doesn't need to be on.

| Quote
lil717 lil717
8/21/2018 2:00 AM

How does the yamaha feel in width around the shrouds now compared to the honda ?

| Quote
tmauto769 tmauto769
8/21/2018 3:46 AM
ML512 wrote:

Nope, just hit the starter ...more

Well isn't that a great idea... Honda/HRC/GET should take note.

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/21/2018 6:54 AM
lil717 wrote:

How does the yamaha feel ...more

Depends on the leg position but the Yamaha still feels a bit bigger at an earlier point and that rolls up to the top, where the Honda feels skinnier at high leg positions due to the shroud ending and not wrapping up to the top of the bike. Maximum width between the two seems to be similar.

| Quote
sandman768 sandman768
8/21/2018 12:44 PM

Which manufacture is your biggest sponsor/advertiser?

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/21/2018 3:03 PM
sandman768 wrote:

Which manufacture is your ...more

KTM for the last two years, prior to that it was Suzuki. In the time I've worked at Vital, five years, Yamaha hasn't ever advertised.

| Quote
Superdave19 Superdave19
8/21/2018 10:03 PM

when/if your test tracks got nasty, which would be yer top 2? Race conditions?

Current rides-
1988 RM250
2019 KX450

| Quote
fpandjic fpandjic
8/22/2018 7:39 AM

I'm also interested in the engine braking. Which one has the most and which one the least engine braking?

Also remember that there was a mentiond of less engine braking map for yamah. Any chance we get that map?

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/22/2018 8:00 AM
fpandjic wrote:

I'm also interested in the ...more

My personal opinion is this for engine braking.

Least to most: Husky then KTM, Kawasaki and Yamaha are pretty close but I'd give the Kawasaki the nod, then the Honda is a bit more than those four but not bad, then the Suzuki still has that old-school four stroke feel...I notice it a ton on this bike.

| Quote
ML512 ML512
8/22/2018 8:01 AM
Superdave19 wrote:

when/if your test tracks ...more

This is of course my opinion, not that of all the test riders, but Kawasaki and Yamaha. Both have phenomenal suspension in stock trim and both chassis help take that extra bit of brunt.

| Quote
PRM31 PRM31
8/22/2018 1:51 PM

How big of a deal is the Yamaha Tuner? It sounds fantastic, but if a bike the Kawi doesn't need a modified tune the value is marginal. Would the same thing be benefical to the Kawi, and if so, by how much?

| Quote
btn
btn
1 of 3

Post a Reply

Cool Wink Smile Tongue Laughing Shocked Sick Angry Blink Sad Unsure Kissing Woohoo Grinning Silly Pinch Sideways Whistling Evil Dizzy Blush Cheerful Huh Dry