Hitch bike carrier questions

davis224
Posts
6250
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL US
Fantasy
165th
Edited Date/Time 10/17/2020 9:20am
Got a new (to me) SUV and am going to put a hitch on and get a hitch mount bike carrier. Any experience on brands? I'm worried about the bolt on hitch handling the weight of the carrier/bike, highest tongue weight offered I've seen is 350 lbs. Looking at Uhaul brand, any other suggestions?

And is the Harbor Freight aluminum bike carrier worth a crap?
|
10/5/2020 5:11am Edited Date/Time 10/5/2020 5:18am
If all you’re going to haul are dirt bikes, this one will get the job done nicely. If you ever plan to haul a street bike, I’d go with the steel version. I have the steel version, and it has performed flawlessly for years.

https://www.discountramps.com/motorcycle-carrier/p/AMC-400/

What SUV are you mounting it on? If you can get a class 3 hitch installed, that will give you 800lb tounge weight. If I was going to use a hitch hauler, I wouldn’t go under a class 3 hitch. A class 2 with a 350 lb tounge weight should work just fine, but class 3 would offer more peace of mind.
10/5/2020 5:15am
Friend of mine uses the HF one. It's holding up fine but we run a tie down over the bed to help support it and keep it from bouncing.
1
soggy
Posts
4885
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
UT US
Fantasy
3846th
10/5/2020 5:26am
The black widow brand is pretty good, better quality then HF. Summit Racing sells them.
2
brian9
Posts
57
Joined
7/2/2018
Location
Panama City Beach, FL US
10/5/2020 5:26am Edited Date/Time 10/5/2020 5:27am
For the hitch, contact a dealer and see what they sell. Then look for aftermarket hitches with the same specs. 350lbs is plenty for most off-road bikes. Towing capacity is always understated, so no worries if you get close to the max.

For a hitch hauler, if you're gonna use it every weekend, the "Add-A-Bike" hauler with the single footpeg post is perfect. Load and unload the bike in 2 seconds, no straps. It's also very light. I've been using it for years hauling a KTM 250SX and I strap a 2-gallon gas can under the bike -- Daystar Cam Can (it's not technically rated for gas for legal reasons). This setup works great.

The Shop

mxdevon
Posts
241
Joined
10/25/2016
Location
Coeur D'Alene, ID US
10/5/2020 7:08am
I’ve used a ton of them. They all get the job done but I really like the ultimate mxhauler . Way expensive but it’s the only one I never worried about my bike on. Also doubles as a work stand at the track.
1
davis224
Posts
6250
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL US
Fantasy
165th
10/5/2020 7:15am
If all you’re going to haul are dirt bikes, this one will get the job done nicely. If you ever plan to haul a street bike...
If all you’re going to haul are dirt bikes, this one will get the job done nicely. If you ever plan to haul a street bike, I’d go with the steel version. I have the steel version, and it has performed flawlessly for years.

https://www.discountramps.com/motorcycle-carrier/p/AMC-400/

What SUV are you mounting it on? If you can get a class 3 hitch installed, that will give you 800lb tounge weight. If I was going to use a hitch hauler, I wouldn’t go under a class 3 hitch. A class 2 with a 350 lb tounge weight should work just fine, but class 3 would offer more peace of mind.
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's rated for 800lb tongue weight. 350 should be fine, but it's close enough to make me think about it breaking off if I hit a big pothole...
brian9
Posts
57
Joined
7/2/2018
Location
Panama City Beach, FL US
10/5/2020 7:26am Edited Date/Time 10/5/2020 7:27am
davis224 wrote:
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's...
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's rated for 800lb tongue weight. 350 should be fine, but it's close enough to make me think about it breaking off if I hit a big pothole...
I had a Mazda CX9, pretty similar with a 350lb tongue weight. I bought a hitch from etrailer.com and had an oil change shop install it for $50. I used a single and a double hitch hauler with it. The single was perfect. The double hauler would sometimes rub the ground when turning into parking lots or driveways with hills. You'll be fine.
mikec265
Posts
1669
Joined
10/19/2015
Location
Edinboro, PA US
10/5/2020 7:36am
I had the same experience as Brian9. You may want to look into air shocks for the rear of the suv. My old jalopy 1999 Escalade really sagged with a 2 bike hualer. Still sagged more than I would like with one bike on it.
str8line
Posts
3660
Joined
9/20/2018
Location
Sandy, UT US
10/5/2020 7:40am
I've been using the Harbor Freight one for a couple of years... over 100 days of use and it's held up fine. Super solid, almost no movement when driving.
3
crusher773
Posts
1759
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Coweta, OK US
10/5/2020 8:11am
I had one for years the double one and never had an issue with it.
Teej317
Posts
680
Joined
4/30/2010
Location
Colstrip, MT US
Fantasy
2060th
10/5/2020 8:17am
str8line wrote:
I've been using the Harbor Freight one for a couple of years... over 100 days of use and it's held up fine. Super solid, almost no...
I've been using the Harbor Freight one for a couple of years... over 100 days of use and it's held up fine. Super solid, almost no movement when driving.
Happy with my HF one as well. Did a 6 hr trip with mine and forgot it was back there (you know...because it worked so well, not because it fell off Smile
10/5/2020 8:43am
If all you’re going to haul are dirt bikes, this one will get the job done nicely. If you ever plan to haul a street bike...
If all you’re going to haul are dirt bikes, this one will get the job done nicely. If you ever plan to haul a street bike, I’d go with the steel version. I have the steel version, and it has performed flawlessly for years.

https://www.discountramps.com/motorcycle-carrier/p/AMC-400/

What SUV are you mounting it on? If you can get a class 3 hitch installed, that will give you 800lb tounge weight. If I was going to use a hitch hauler, I wouldn’t go under a class 3 hitch. A class 2 with a 350 lb tounge weight should work just fine, but class 3 would offer more peace of mind.
davis224 wrote:
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's...
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's rated for 800lb tongue weight. 350 should be fine, but it's close enough to make me think about it breaking off if I hit a big pothole...
That’s a crossover, not an SUV, so it might be tough to get a class 3 hitch installed on it. At any rate, I don’t have any experience mounting hitch haulers on crossovers, so I’m afraid I won’t be of much help. As I’ve stated, I have had good luck with discountramps.com products, so you might want to give them a call to see if they have any advice for you.
toomanykaws
Posts
394
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Henderson, NV US
10/5/2020 8:47am
Originally got a Harbor Fright hauler for moving bikes between my house and shop where I work on them. Ended up bolting one the Harbor bike wheel chocks on it. So I am $130 total into it. Hard to beat the super coupons. It’s fine for any my 125-500s. But my 690r seems to make it flex. A bit.
FWYT
Posts
3308
Joined
5/25/2014
Location
San Diego, CA US
10/5/2020 9:00am
Originally got a Harbor Fright hauler for moving bikes between my house and shop where I work on them. Ended up bolting one the Harbor bike...
Originally got a Harbor Fright hauler for moving bikes between my house and shop where I work on them. Ended up bolting one the Harbor bike wheel chocks on it. So I am $130 total into it. Hard to beat the super coupons. It’s fine for any my 125-500s. But my 690r seems to make it flex. A bit.
You put your 690 on the HF carrier? Dang! What car is that carrier mounted to?
(I have a KTM 640 and want to do this but it seems a bit much.)
TeamGreen
Posts
28979
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA US
10/5/2020 9:30am
str8line wrote:
I've been using the Harbor Freight one for a couple of years... over 100 days of use and it's held up fine. Super solid, almost no...
I've been using the Harbor Freight one for a couple of years... over 100 days of use and it's held up fine. Super solid, almost no movement when driving.
Teej317 wrote:
Happy with my HF one as well. Did a 6 hr trip with mine and forgot it was back there (you know...because it worked so well...
Happy with my HF one as well. Did a 6 hr trip with mine and forgot it was back there (you know...because it worked so well, not because it fell off Smile
2019

The only vehicle I had with me to get my bike from Redding to Mammoth was an Escalade. The only carrier I could find was at Harbor Freight. It worked really well.

Good luck.



3
10/5/2020 9:37am Edited Date/Time 10/5/2020 9:42am
davis224 wrote:
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's...
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's rated for 800lb tongue weight. 350 should be fine, but it's close enough to make me think about it breaking off if I hit a big pothole...
Go to etrailer.com or other such source for class III hitches to install. Just because its a class III, doesnt always mean its rated for 800lbs. Models and applications can vary, but even if only 600lbs, it would still be an improvement over a class II 1 1/2" receiver with a much lower tongue weight rating... I wouldn't recommend a class II in my experience unless there is no other choice.

Remember that more often than not, the actual weight is going to be carried further back than where the ball is usually mounted and rated, acting like a lever increasing the force at the receiver.. So you want a considerable fudge factor in your favor in my opinion.

As already mentioned, you may or may not need helper springs. In addition, the further back off the bumper and away from your rear axle, the more the weight will be felt when driving (especially vehicles with shorter wheelbases.) Trucks and full size SUVs don't seem to even notice.

I run the Ultimate MXhauler on a class III hitch mounted to my Land Rover Discovery II. The disco has a relatively short wheel base with a long rear overhang and a spare to clear, so the bike is way back. Adding to it, the disco is lifted slightly with a soft offroad shocks. The receiver and carrier are stout, but I do feel the weight back there. Fine with my dirtbikes, but I've carried an XR650L a few times at 350lbs + and wouldnt do it regularly, with my rig as set up. Needed to really slow down on the twisty mtn roads. Just my experience.

That said, I've seen Outbacks, Elements, etc haul just fine with a bit reason. Buddies FJ with similar wheelbase but less rear overhang carries bikes with the same Ultimate MxHauler without a fuss, likes its not even there. I suspect my extreme overhang and offroad set up are responsible for my results.

Just things to consider when setting up your system.
3
kb228
Posts
6161
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
10/5/2020 9:47am
I bought one for $80 from walmart i believe. Works perfect. Only complaint is the little ramp isnt wide enough for the rear tire on my 450. I run the 120 rear tire.

I have an f150, so theres not tongue weight concern.
toomanykaws
Posts
394
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Henderson, NV US
10/5/2020 9:49am
Originally got a Harbor Fright hauler for moving bikes between my house and shop where I work on them. Ended up bolting one the Harbor bike...
Originally got a Harbor Fright hauler for moving bikes between my house and shop where I work on them. Ended up bolting one the Harbor bike wheel chocks on it. So I am $130 total into it. Hard to beat the super coupons. It’s fine for any my 125-500s. But my 690r seems to make it flex. A bit.
FWYT wrote:
You put your 690 on the HF carrier? Dang! What car is that carrier mounted to? (I have a KTM 640 and want to do this...
You put your 690 on the HF carrier? Dang! What car is that carrier mounted to?
(I have a KTM 640 and want to do this but it seems a bit much.)
2000 Silverado. Was an old guy truck. Pretty mint. Has one those fiberglass flip up tonneau. And a complete Bed Rug. It’s so handy hauling and locking stuff up. I never removed it. Is why I got the hitch carrier.
1
Tim507
Posts
3144
Joined
6/8/2010
Location
Oregon City, OR US
10/5/2020 9:52am
I've been using one of these for years, durable!!! Big Bikes or small bikes


1
1
dfr136
Posts
170
Joined
8/25/2019
Location
IL US
Fantasy
921st
10/5/2020 11:52am Edited Date/Time 10/5/2020 4:35pm
I bought this one this year and its probably one of the best things Ive ever bought. https://racknride.com/

I also have a cx5 I put a class three on a few years ago, have never used the hitch hauler but we have towed a small 4x8 with two bikes all over the place with no issues the car towed it great.



ToolMaker
Posts
6111
Joined
11/19/2011
Location
Escondido, CA US
Fantasy
762nd
10/5/2020 12:19pm
davis224 wrote:
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's...
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's rated for 800lb tongue weight. 350 should be fine, but it's close enough to make me think about it breaking off if I hit a big pothole...
the problem you'll have with the CX5 is by the time you get your hitch receiver mounted it's so low to the ground,
just about every dip you'll be grinding your carrier on the ground.

With this in mind we built a few just for those CX5s and some others with the same problem.
It's not a standard offering so it's not like you could call and get one shipped right out but this is what you need,
It's the Switch Hauler® with the 3 inch lift.
If you have any questions you could PM me



5
chasetwo79
Posts
1030
Joined
12/1/2019
Location
Truckee, CA, CA US
10/5/2020 2:07pm
I say check out Add a bike. I’ve driven across the country and use it all the time when I don’t feel like pulling a trailer.

I’ve had mine for 4 years and it’s still going strong.

www.addabike.com
davis224
Posts
6250
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL US
Fantasy
165th
10/5/2020 2:48pm
davis224 wrote:
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's...
Mazda CX5, I haven't done a ton of digging, but if it's just mounted with 1/2" bolts, I'm not sure I could find a hitch that's rated for 800lb tongue weight. 350 should be fine, but it's close enough to make me think about it breaking off if I hit a big pothole...
ToolMaker wrote:
the problem you'll have with the CX5 is by the time you get your hitch receiver mounted it's so low to the ground, just about every...
the problem you'll have with the CX5 is by the time you get your hitch receiver mounted it's so low to the ground,
just about every dip you'll be grinding your carrier on the ground.

With this in mind we built a few just for those CX5s and some others with the same problem.
It's not a standard offering so it's not like you could call and get one shipped right out but this is what you need,
It's the Switch Hauler® with the 3 inch lift.
If you have any questions you could PM me



This is what I was afraid of, I really don't want to go through the hassle of finding a small trailer cheap enough and paying the newly increased registration fees on it... but I want the bike carrier to work and not worry about driving down a bumpy country road.
Mx746
Posts
533
Joined
11/30/2010
Location
Marietta, GA US
10/5/2020 4:19pm
20 years on my motojackrack doubles as a work stand. Love it. Bulletproof. Modern version is the ultimate mx hauler
FWYT
Posts
3308
Joined
5/25/2014
Location
San Diego, CA US
10/5/2020 9:11pm Edited Date/Time 10/5/2020 9:27pm
Semi related-
I made this set up for my Escape a couple years ago and it works FANTASTIC. (Team Green has seen it in action and can verify. Smile )

I welded some receivers to the sides of the factory class II hitch. Then those hoops just slide in when needed. The middle receiver is used as the mounting point and those load links hold the bike SOLID. When not in use, the pieces just sit out of the way in the back of the car. Nothing to stash on the side of the house or anything. Works unreal. I'm actually working on V 2.0 at the moment that is going to be even better.







12
Hcallz5
Posts
2845
Joined
8/20/2013
Location
UT US
10/5/2020 9:41pm
I bought one from a local welder for like $120, says it will hold 400lbs. It's heavy but works great.

That black widow one looks nice for the price.
Bultaco
Posts
1728
Joined
1/20/2014
Location
Planet, VT US
10/6/2020 2:13am
Just used the HF one to haul my 200 EXC,1600 miles and back. No complaints.

Post a reply to: Hitch bike carrier questions

The Latest