MC= Brady RC= Favre

gnarwhip
Profile picture for user gnarwhip
Posts
1972
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Los Angeles, CA US
gnarwhip
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC the he GOAT cus he's not.
|
feelnjstfine
Profile picture for user feelnjstfine
Posts
207
Joined
8/9/2009
Location
Portland, OR US
feelnjstfine 2/10/2018 9:14pm
2/10/2018 9:14pm Edited Date/Time 2/10/2018 9:18pm
McGrath had 17 wins and 1 Championship outdoors to Carmichaels 102 wins and 10 Championships. MC is no doubt the King of Supercross, but RC is definitely the GOAT of MX overall
SoCalMX70
Profile picture for user SoCalMX70
Posts
2821
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA US
SoCalMX70 2/10/2018 9:20pm
2/10/2018 9:20pm
TheOriginalPancakee wrote:
And then came Carmichael and it took him a year before he started dominating everyone
Wow twice in one day...

Took RC TWO years. Tongue
lappedrider
Profile picture for user lappedrider
Posts
868
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Tooele, UT US
lappedrider 2/10/2018 9:20pm
2/10/2018 9:20pm Edited Date/Time 2/10/2018 9:22pm
MC is the 2nd best dirtbike racer in history. There is no shame in that.

The Shop

See All »
Park Boys
Profile picture for user Park Boys
Posts
3579
Joined
3/23/2012
Location
MH US
Fantasy
32nd
Park Boys 2/10/2018 9:21pm
2/10/2018 9:21pm
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's not even dabatable RC is the goat, he literally retired MC made it so he could never win a race again at his game and then made sure the 2nd and 4th winningest riders of SX history never beat him for a title.
Park Boys
Profile picture for user Park Boys
Posts
3579
Joined
3/23/2012
Location
MH US
Fantasy
32nd
Park Boys 2/10/2018 9:26pm
2/10/2018 9:26pm
lappedrider wrote:
MC is the 2nd best dirtbike racer in history. There is no shame in that.
False, behind RC, RJ, Hannah and RV. SX only yes. Overall no.
Racer111
Profile picture for user Racer111
Posts
2767
Joined
5/23/2009
Location
Concord, NC US
Racer111 2/10/2018 9:51pm
2/10/2018 9:51pm
Park Boys wrote:
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's...
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's not even dabatable RC is the goat, he literally retired MC made it so he could never win a race again at his game and then made sure the 2nd and 4th winningest riders of SX history never beat him for a title.
MC dominated the class for 8 years before RC came along. And when RC DID come along, he got dominated by MC for 2 years. RC didn’t retire MC. MC had been racing Supercross longer than RC actually raced SX before RC even came along.
Park Boys
Profile picture for user Park Boys
Posts
3579
Joined
3/23/2012
Location
MH US
Fantasy
32nd
Park Boys 2/10/2018 10:05pm
2/10/2018 10:05pm
Park Boys wrote:
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's...
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's not even dabatable RC is the goat, he literally retired MC made it so he could never win a race again at his game and then made sure the 2nd and 4th winningest riders of SX history never beat him for a title.
Racer111 wrote:
MC dominated the class for 8 years before RC came along. And when RC DID come along, he got dominated by MC for 2 years. RC...
MC dominated the class for 8 years before RC came along. And when RC DID come along, he got dominated by MC for 2 years. RC didn’t retire MC. MC had been racing Supercross longer than RC actually raced SX before RC even came along.
7 years slick. Sure he beat RC the first two years but RC had no business racing SX in 99 he had only raced two 125 seasons at that point. Like I said 15 out of 17 titles won. No debate. Yes RC retired MC, MC had his second best season in 2000 then RC came along in 01. But the reason you could say MC had his second best season in 2000 could be because Yogi got hurt in round 1 in 2000 still MC would have been title favorite in 2000 any ways.
Park Boys
Profile picture for user Park Boys
Posts
3579
Joined
3/23/2012
Location
MH US
Fantasy
32nd
Park Boys 2/10/2018 10:05pm
2/10/2018 10:05pm
Park Boys wrote:
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's...
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's not even dabatable RC is the goat, he literally retired MC made it so he could never win a race again at his game and then made sure the 2nd and 4th winningest riders of SX history never beat him for a title.
Racer111 wrote:
MC dominated the class for 8 years before RC came along. And when RC DID come along, he got dominated by MC for 2 years. RC...
MC dominated the class for 8 years before RC came along. And when RC DID come along, he got dominated by MC for 2 years. RC didn’t retire MC. MC had been racing Supercross longer than RC actually raced SX before RC even came along.
7 years slick. Sure he beat RC the first two years but RC had no business racing SX in 99 he had only raced two 125 seasons at that point. Like I said 15 out of 17 titles won. No debate. Yes RC retired MC, MC had his second best season in 2000 then RC came along in 01. But the reason you could say MC had his second best season in 2000 could be because Yogi got hurt in round 1 in 2000 still MC would have been title favorite in 2000 any ways.
wreckitrandy
Profile picture for user wreckitrandy
Posts
3854
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC US
wreckitrandy 2/10/2018 10:51pm
2/10/2018 10:51pm
Not even good bait. Contrary to what a lot of limp wristed snowflakes think, stoopie cross just ain't all that. If it were, why do people want to change the format, reset,,, chase. I find it interesting that MC won so many SX races and titles but none of his little fan boys ever got tired of it then. MC should be very satisfied to be the King of SX. He should also show some grace and accept that his decision to race SX only, excludes him from even being in the running for GOAT. The numbers don't lie, 150 wins, 15 titles, 10 straight outdoor titles, 2 perfect seasons and another season of 12 straight overalls. To put it into perspective, RC's numbers equal MC's and Jeff Ward's put together.
Racer111
Profile picture for user Racer111
Posts
2767
Joined
5/23/2009
Location
Concord, NC US
Racer111 2/11/2018 9:15am
2/11/2018 9:15am Edited Date/Time 2/11/2018 9:16am
Park Boys wrote:
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's...
Well considering RC won 15 out of 17 championships entrered it's not even close. Remember RC won his 5th SX title when he was 26. It's not even dabatable RC is the goat, he literally retired MC made it so he could never win a race again at his game and then made sure the 2nd and 4th winningest riders of SX history never beat him for a title.
Racer111 wrote:
MC dominated the class for 8 years before RC came along. And when RC DID come along, he got dominated by MC for 2 years. RC...
MC dominated the class for 8 years before RC came along. And when RC DID come along, he got dominated by MC for 2 years. RC didn’t retire MC. MC had been racing Supercross longer than RC actually raced SX before RC even came along.
Park Boys wrote:
7 years slick. Sure he beat RC the first two years but RC had no business racing SX in 99 he had only raced two 125...
7 years slick. Sure he beat RC the first two years but RC had no business racing SX in 99 he had only raced two 125 seasons at that point. Like I said 15 out of 17 titles won. No debate. Yes RC retired MC, MC had his second best season in 2000 then RC came along in 01. But the reason you could say MC had his second best season in 2000 could be because Yogi got hurt in round 1 in 2000 still MC would have been title favorite in 2000 any ways.
Really? MC only raced 2 seasons in the 125 class. Came in as a rookie and DOMINATED against a much higher stacked field. And thanks for proving my point. RC only raced 7 full seasons of SX. MC had raced that many before RC even showed up and STILL got waxed by the King for 2 years.

You obviously weren’t even born yet when MC was killing everyone. And we all know how 2007 would have turned out had RC raced the full series. He even got smoked his last SC race. Hell, we all know how the 2006 SX season would have ended had RC not whined and bitched about his 25 point fuel infraction. He’s the ONLY racer to ever get one and have it overturned because he said he was going to pick up his ball and go home if they didn’t. That’s fact.

RC was the best outdoors for sure, but MC ruled and continues to rule the stadiums. Period!
DonM
Profile picture for user DonM
Posts
6753
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
DonM 2/11/2018 9:19am
2/11/2018 9:19am
It's all about total wins and championships in both SX and MX....end of story
mooch
Profile picture for user mooch
Posts
1387
Joined
2/16/2008
Location
OH US
Fantasy
501st
mooch 2/11/2018 9:43am
2/11/2018 9:43am
gnarwhip wrote:
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC...
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC the he GOAT cus he's not.
This thread...Yet another attempt to get attention from an attention whore.
scott_nz
Profile picture for user scott_nz
Posts
5319
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NZ
Fantasy
655th
scott_nz 2/11/2018 9:48am
2/11/2018 9:48am Edited Date/Time 2/11/2018 9:49am
Racer111 wrote:
Really? MC only raced 2 seasons in the 125 class. Came in as a rookie and DOMINATED against a much higher stacked field. And thanks for...
Really? MC only raced 2 seasons in the 125 class. Came in as a rookie and DOMINATED against a much higher stacked field. And thanks for proving my point. RC only raced 7 full seasons of SX. MC had raced that many before RC even showed up and STILL got waxed by the King for 2 years.

You obviously weren’t even born yet when MC was killing everyone. And we all know how 2007 would have turned out had RC raced the full series. He even got smoked his last SC race. Hell, we all know how the 2006 SX season would have ended had RC not whined and bitched about his 25 point fuel infraction. He’s the ONLY racer to ever get one and have it overturned because he said he was going to pick up his ball and go home if they didn’t. That’s fact.

RC was the best outdoors for sure, but MC ruled and continues to rule the stadiums. Period!
MC did 3 seasons on a 125, first in 1990 on a KX125 where he won the final round, then 2 seasons on the PC Peak Honda where he one the title both years,
cbuehler767
Profile picture for user cbuehler767
Posts
750
Joined
1/27/2016
Location
New London, CT US
cbuehler767 2/11/2018 10:01am
2/11/2018 10:01am
RC is the best overall racer of all time. Like Park Boys said is MC even in the top 5? What would you rather be the best at motocross or circuscross?
JW381
Profile picture for user JW381
Posts
10642
Joined
7/21/2009
Location
Harrisburg, OR US
JW381 2/11/2018 10:14am
2/11/2018 10:14am
Lol

Pit Row

See All »
ToolMaker
Profile picture for user ToolMaker
Posts
6097
Joined
11/19/2011
Location
Escondido, CA US
Fantasy
762nd
ToolMaker 2/11/2018 10:31am
2/11/2018 10:31am
lappedrider wrote:
MC is the 2nd best dirtbike racer in history. There is no shame in that.
While it may be that nobody dethrones MC in SX, if you use the term "dirtbike racer"
do you have no love for Stefan Everts?
TM
Racer111
Profile picture for user Racer111
Posts
2767
Joined
5/23/2009
Location
Concord, NC US
Racer111 2/11/2018 11:28am
2/11/2018 11:28am
Racer111 wrote:
Really? MC only raced 2 seasons in the 125 class. Came in as a rookie and DOMINATED against a much higher stacked field. And thanks for...
Really? MC only raced 2 seasons in the 125 class. Came in as a rookie and DOMINATED against a much higher stacked field. And thanks for proving my point. RC only raced 7 full seasons of SX. MC had raced that many before RC even showed up and STILL got waxed by the King for 2 years.

You obviously weren’t even born yet when MC was killing everyone. And we all know how 2007 would have turned out had RC raced the full series. He even got smoked his last SC race. Hell, we all know how the 2006 SX season would have ended had RC not whined and bitched about his 25 point fuel infraction. He’s the ONLY racer to ever get one and have it overturned because he said he was going to pick up his ball and go home if they didn’t. That’s fact.

RC was the best outdoors for sure, but MC ruled and continues to rule the stadiums. Period!
scott_nz wrote:
MC did 3 seasons on a 125, first in 1990 on a KX125 where he won the final round, then 2 seasons on the PC Peak...
MC did 3 seasons on a 125, first in 1990 on a KX125 where he won the final round, then 2 seasons on the PC Peak Honda where he one the title both years,
He raced ONE race that year, which was Seattle. He didn’t race the full West Coast. And they only raced 6-7 total rounds then. Not 8. I’d be willing to bet RC has more 125 SX starts than MC does.
BobbyM
Profile picture for user BobbyM
Posts
21449
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
AZ US
BobbyM 2/11/2018 11:33am
2/11/2018 11:33am
gnarwhip wrote:
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC...
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC the he GOAT cus he's not.
Joe Montana is the goat
cali11
Profile picture for user cali11
Posts
1547
Joined
2/28/2016
Location
Federal Way, WA US
cali11 2/11/2018 11:38am
2/11/2018 11:38am
gnarwhip wrote:
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC...
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC the he GOAT cus he's not.
wtf?
scott_nz
Profile picture for user scott_nz
Posts
5319
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NZ
Fantasy
655th
scott_nz 2/11/2018 9:58pm
2/11/2018 9:58pm Edited Date/Time 2/11/2018 9:58pm
Racer111 wrote:
He raced ONE race that year, which was Seattle. He didn’t race the full West Coast. And they only raced 6-7 total rounds then. Not 8...
He raced ONE race that year, which was Seattle. He didn’t race the full West Coast. And they only raced 6-7 total rounds then. Not 8. I’d be willing to bet RC has more 125 SX starts than MC does.
he was 8th in points in 1989, with 71 points, bit more than one race,
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1989/sx/points

he was 2nd in points in 1990
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1990/sx/points

and then won the west title in 91 and 92,
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1991/sx/points
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1992/sx/points

he raced 4 seasons in 125's, when they also had 3 or 4 east west races a year,

dirtnapper
Profile picture for user dirtnapper
Posts
5457
Joined
4/14/2011
Location
Alberta CA
dirtnapper 2/11/2018 10:17pm
2/11/2018 10:17pm
gnarwhip wrote:
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC...
Always pisses me off when people call RC the GOAT, when MC has 72 sx wins and RC has only 48 sx wins. Stop calling RC the he GOAT cus he's not.
mooch wrote:
This thread...Yet another attempt to get attention from an attention whore.
Laughing
web mx
Profile picture for user web mx
Posts
741
Joined
3/3/2010
Location
USA, MI US
web mx 2/12/2018 9:52am
2/12/2018 9:52am
Racer111 wrote:
He raced ONE race that year, which was Seattle. He didn’t race the full West Coast. And they only raced 6-7 total rounds then. Not 8...
He raced ONE race that year, which was Seattle. He didn’t race the full West Coast. And they only raced 6-7 total rounds then. Not 8. I’d be willing to bet RC has more 125 SX starts than MC does.
scott_nz wrote:
he was 8th in points in 1989, with 71 points, bit more than one race, https://vault.racerxonline.com/1989/sx/points he was 2nd in points in 1990 https://vault.racerxonline.com/1990/sx/points and then...
he was 8th in points in 1989, with 71 points, bit more than one race,
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1989/sx/points

he was 2nd in points in 1990
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1990/sx/points

and then won the west title in 91 and 92,
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1991/sx/points
https://vault.racerxonline.com/1992/sx/points

he raced 4 seasons in 125's, when they also had 3 or 4 east west races a year,

I was about to put this out there but glad i read all thru the post's toi see scott_nz got it. I always wondered why alot of MC fan's believed 91 was his rookie season and that he raced 125 SX only 2 years
web mx
Profile picture for user web mx
Posts
741
Joined
3/3/2010
Location
USA, MI US
web mx 2/12/2018 9:57am
2/12/2018 9:57am
Racer111 wrote:
He raced ONE race that year, which was Seattle. He didn’t race the full West Coast. And they only raced 6-7 total rounds then. Not 8...
He raced ONE race that year, which was Seattle. He didn’t race the full West Coast. And they only raced 6-7 total rounds then. Not 8. I’d be willing to bet RC has more 125 SX starts than MC does.
I think you should check your facts first,In 90 thru 92 there were 17 or 18 rounds each year and they had at least 8 or more 125 sx races for each series and a couple of east/west combined rounds.
doghouse
Profile picture for user doghouse
Posts
548
Joined
1/7/2017
Location
Virginia Beach, VA US
doghouse 2/12/2018 10:12am
2/12/2018 10:12am
This is worse than an offseason thread.

Post a reply to: MC= Brady RC= Favre